hey mac lovers!

i have a weird question and figured y'all as makeup fiends could help. i currently use mac's antiqued to fill in my brows. (i dye my hair a really obnoxious color of red and antiqued is a nice balance of red-brown to make the brows still look natural!) however, i seem to have managed to misplace it (woe!) and i need to find something similar quickly.

what i'm looking for:
- something red/brown, maybe a shade or two darker than antiqued
- preferably not-shimmery like antiqued is, maybe a matte?

does anyone have any recs? i'd actually prefer something drugstore, but something mac could work as well!

thanks guys!